Spire: The city must fall - Starter guide

What is Spire: The city must fall?

Spire: The City Must Fall is a fantasy-punk roleplaying game about revolution, sacrifice, and survival under an oppressive regime. Designed by Grant Howitt and Chris Taylor and published by Rowan, Rook and Decard in 2018, it puts you inside a mile-high city called Spire - an ancient, labyrinthine metropolis that was conquered two centuries ago by the aelfir, the high elves, who now rule through fear and exploitation.

You play as drow, the dark elves who built this city and now live as second-class citizens within it. Your characters are members of a secret cell sworn to a forbidden goddess of shadows, and your mission is to dismantle the regime by any means necessary: espionage, blackmail, illegal magic, and outright violence. Spire does not promise victory. It promises consequences.

The tone sits somewhere between gothic fantasy, urban noir, and political horror. Think less dungeon crawl, more underground resistance movement. The city itself - with its warped districts, strange factions, bleeding wounds in reality, and mad cannibal kings beneath abandoned warehouses - is as much a character as the people in it.

How does the system work?

Spire uses the Resistance System, a dice pool mechanic built entirely around d10s. When your character attempts something difficult, you roll a pool of d10s and look for the highest result. The size of your pool depends on your relevant skill and whether you have a domain that applies to the situation. Difficult circumstances reduce your pool.

The key design tension lives in the Stress and Fallout mechanics. When actions go wrong, you take Stress in one of five categories: Blood (physical harm), Mind (psychological damage), Silver (financial loss), Shadow (drawing dangerous attention), and Reputation (your standing in the community). These tracks are not simple hit points. They reflect the cost of revolution in concrete, flavourful terms.

When Stress accumulates, you risk suffering Fallout - a lasting consequence determined by the fiction and negotiated between player and GM. Fallout ranges from a broken limb to financial ruin to permanently warped perception from practising forbidden magic. Importantly, character death is a player choice in Spire. You can keep pushing through permanent injury, mental collapse, and ruin. The question is whether you want to.

Characters are defined by one of ten classes, each deeply embedded in the fiction of the city. The Knight swaggers through backstreet brawls on reputation and bravado. The Idol is a supernaturally gifted artist who bends minds through craft. The Vermissian Sage haunts the corrupted tunnels of a failed underground transit system. The Midwife is an arachnid nurse with unsettling medical abilities. Every class comes with its own flavour and narrative weight - choosing one feels like choosing a role in the revolution, not just a set of statistics.

Characters also have Bonds: NPC contacts such as friends, family members, or allies they can call upon for help. The more you rely on them, the greater the risk they take Fallout themselves. This mechanic puts the cost of resistance on the people around you, not just your character sheet.

What do you need to start?

The core rulebook is the only thing strictly required. It is a 232-page hardcover that contains the full rules, all ten character classes, detailed lore on Spire's districts and factions, and a GM chapter focused on building conspiracies and power structures for your players to dismantle.

A free Pay What You Want quickstart is available on DriveThruRPG, which includes streamlined rules, pre-generated characters, and a starter scenario. It is a good way to get a feel for the game before committing to the full book.

Rowan, Rook and Decard have also published a range of supplements including Strata (a sourcebook packed with new rules and scenarios), Sin (covering crime, religion, and order in Spire), The Magister's Guide (GM tools and extra class content), and several shorter one-shot collections and setting expansions. None of these are required to begin, but they deepen the world considerably.

Who is this game for?

Spire is an excellent fit for groups that want narrative-driven play with genuine political and emotional weight. If your table is drawn to stories about oppression, resistance, and the personal cost of fighting back - and is comfortable with themes of violence, moral ambiguity, and systemic injustice - this game will reward you.

It works especially well for players who enjoy roleplaying in highly atmospheric settings where the world itself feels alive and threatening. The GM chapter is thoughtfully designed to help you build conspiracies and factions without needing to prep exhaustively.

It is less suited to groups who want tactical combat, dungeon exploration, or lighter fare. The mechanics are narrative first and foremost - there are no battle maps, no initiative trackers, no grid. Combat is fluid and story-driven, and that requires a table willing to lean into fiction over procedure.

How does it compare to other systems?

The closest comparison is Blades in the Dark. Both are story-driven games about criminals and revolutionaries operating in a dangerous city, both use dice pools with similar tension mechanics, and both put the city itself at the centre of play. Spire is arguably more setting-specific and less modular than Blades - the world of Spire is densely built and inseparable from the game's identity. Where Blades gives you a toolkit for building heist crews, Spire gives you a world to inhabit.

Compared to Dungeons & Dragons, the differences are fundamental. Character death is optional, success and failure are contextual rather than numerical, and the entire structure of the game is built around telling a specific kind of story. D&D players who come to Spire expecting dungeon runs will find something quite different - and potentially much more interesting.

Where do you start?

Begin with the quickstart if you want a low-stakes way to try the system. If you have already committed to the core book, start by reading the setting chapter before anything else. The world of Spire needs to be in your head before the mechanics will fully make sense.

For your first session, character creation is the best starting point. The class choices and Bond selections will naturally generate story questions that can anchor your first mission. Let the players' choices guide the shape of your opening scenario rather than preparing extensively in advance.

Useful external resources include the Rowan, Rook and Decard website, where free supplemental tools such as the Resistance Toolbox SRD are available. There is also an active community on Reddit (r/bladesinthedark covers the Resistance System family of games) and YouTube, where actual play videos give a good sense of how sessions actually flow.

Recommended products at Netherbook

The core rulebook, Spire: The City Must Fall, is the essential starting point and a beautifully produced book in its own right.